Theoretical Implications of Object Clitic Omission in Early French: spontaneous vs. Elicited Production

• Autores: Mihaela Pirvulescu
• Localización: Catalan journal of linguistics, ISSN-e 2014-9719, ISSN 1695-6885, Vol. 5, 2006 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Acquisition of Romance languages), págs. 221-226
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.5565/rev/catjl.70
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo  1    2  
• Dialnet Métricas: 1 Cita
• Resumen

  • This article examines the phenomenon of object clitic omission in French. Previous research contains contradictory results depending on the source of the data: it seems that in spontaneous production children prefer DPs while in elicited production they prefer omissions. It is proposed that a common methodology be used across different modalities in measuring the rate of omissions, and that the notion of «illicit object omission» be dispensed with. The analysis of the proposed «clitic-contexts» reveals that the strategy favoured by children is omission of all kinds of lexical material in both spontaneous and elicited production. Moreover, it is shown that child behaviour is quantitatively different from the adult one. These findings have consequences on the status of null objects in child grammar: child grammar allows optional object deletion without clitic recoverability, as opposed to adult grammar. Several theoretical approaches are evaluated in the light of the new findings.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Belletti, Adriana; Hamann, Cornelia (2004). «On the L2/bilingual acquisition of French by two young children with different source languages»....
  • Cardinaletti, Anna; Starke, Michal (1999). «The typology of structural deficiency: a case study of the three classes of pronouns». In Clitics...
  • Cummins, Sarah; Roberge, Yves (2005). «A Modular Account of Null Objects in French». Syntax 8: 44-64.
  • Farkas, Donka (2002). «Specificity distinctions». Journal of Semantics 19, 213-243.
  • Fonágy, Ivan (1985) «J’aime ?. Je connais ?. Verbes transitifs à objet latent». Revue Romane 20. 3-35.
  • Friedemann, Marc-Ariel (1992). «The underlying position of external arguments in French», Geneva generative papers 0 (1-2), 123-144.
  • Grüter, Teres (in progress). Object clitics and null objects in the acquisition of French, Doctoral Thesis in preparation, McGill University.
  • Hamann, Cornelia (2002). From syntax to discourse. Pronominal clitics, null subjects and infinitives in child language. Kluwer: Dordrecht.
  • Hamann, Cornelia (2003). «Phenomena in French normal and impaired language acquisition and their implications for hypotheses on language development»....
  • Hamann, Cornelia; Rizzi, Luigi; Frauenfelder, Ulrich (1996). «The acquisition of subject and object clitics in French». In Generative Perspectives...
  • Hamann, Cornelia; Cronel-Ohayon, Stephany; Dubé, Sébastien; Frauenfelder, Ulrich; Rizzi, Luigi; Starke, Michal; Zesinger, Pascal (in press)....
  • Jakubowicz, Celia; Müller, Natascha; Kang, Ok-Kyung; Riemer, Beate; Rigaut, Catherine (1996). «On the acquisition of the pronominal system...
  • Jakubowicz, Celia; Müller, Natascha; Riemer, Beate; Rigaut, Catherine (1997). «The case of subject and object omissions in French and German»....
  • Jakubowicz, Celia; Nash, Lea; Rigaut, Catherine; Christophe-Loic, G. (1998). «Determiners and clitic pronouns in French-speaking children...
  • Jakubowicz, Celia; Rigaut, Catherine (2000). «L’acquisition des clitiques nominatifs et des clitiques objets en français». Canadian Journal...
  • Jakubowicz, Celia; Nash, Lea (2001). «Functional categories and syntactic operations in (ab)normal language acquisition». Brain and Language...
  • Jakubowicz, Celia; Nash, Lea (to appear). «Why accusative clitics are avoided in normal and impaired language development». In Essays in syntax,...
  • Lambrecht, Knud; Lemoine, Kevin (2004). «Definite null objects in (spoken) French.A construction-grammar approach». To appear in Construction...
  • Larjavaara, Meri (2000). Présence ou absence de l’objet. Limites du possible en français contemporain. Helsinki: Academia Scientiarum Fennica.
  • López, Luis (2003). «Steps for a well-adjusted dislocation». Studia Linguistica 57 (3): 193-231.
  • Müller, Natascha (2004). «Null-arguments in bilingual children». The acquisition of French in different contexts ed. by P. Prévost and J....
  • Müller, Natascha; Hulk; Aafke (2001). «Crosslinguistic influence in bilingual language acquisition: Italian and French as recipient languages»....
  • Müller, Natascha; Hulk; Aafke (2000). «Crosslinguistic influence in bilingual children: object omissions and root infinitives». In Proceedings...
  • Müller, Natascha; Crysmann, Berthold; Kaiser, Georg A. (1996). «Interactions between the acquisition of French object drop and the development...
  • Pérez-Leroux, Ana; Pirvulescu, Mihaela; Roberge, Yves (to appear). «Early object omission in child French and English». Selected Papers from...
  • Pérez-Leroux, Ana; Pirvulescu, Mihaela; Roberge, Yves (in preparation). «A syntactic transitivity approach to null objects in child language»....
  • Pirvulescu, Mihaela (to appear). «The acquisition of object clitics in French L1: spontaneous vs. elicited production». Proceedings of GALA...
  • Pirvulescu, Mihaela; Roberge, Yves (2005). «Licit and Illicit Null Objects in L1 French». In Theoretical and Experimental Approaches to Romance...
  • Schaeffer, Jeannette (2000). The Acquisition of Direct Object Scrambling and Clitic Placement. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
  • Schmitz, Katrin; Cantone, Katja; Müller, Natascha; Kupisch, Tanja (2004). «Clitic realizations and omissions in early child grammar: a comparison...
  • Tsakali, Vina; Wexler, Ken (2004). «Why children omit clitics in some languages but not in others: new evidence from Greek». Proceedings of...
  • Van der Velde, Marlies; Jakubowicz, Celia; Rigaut, Catherine (2002). «The acquisition of determiner phrase and pronominal clitics by three...
  • Wexler, Kenneth (1998). «Very early parameter setting and the unique checking constraint: a new explanation of the optional infinitive stage»....
  • Wexler, Kenneth; Gavarró, Anna; Torrens, Vicenç (2004). «Feature checking and object clitic omission in child Catalan». In (eds.). Romance...